A recent article in U.S. Catholic magazine, authored by Kevin Beck, proposes an "expansion" of the Holy Rosary through the creation of 35 new mysteries, grouped into seven thematic sets based on the Acts of the Apostles. Titled "synodal mysteries," these new sets ("attentive," "pentecostal," "ecclesial," "evangelization," "reconciliation," "missional," and "pilgrimage") are presented as a way to meditate on synodality, inspired by what the author describes as the Church's "original synod," the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15). The author argues that, like the traditional mysteries, these new ones yield specific fruits, such as "inclusion," "dialogue," "diversity," and "collaboration."
A critical analysis from a traditional Catholic perspective vehemently rejects this proposal. It is argued that such an initiative constitutes not an expansion but a dissolution of the Rosary, cheapening a sacred devotion and opening the door to an infinity of subjective innovations. The critique contrasts the theocentric nature of the traditional mysteries, focused on the lives of Christ and the Virgin Mary, with the procedural and humanistic focus of the new mysteries. Additionally, the critique defends the numerical and theological integrity of the traditional Rosary (the 150 Hail Marys corresponding to the 150 Psalms), citing papal documents from St. Pius V, Leo XIII, and Pius XI that reinforce its immutable structure and purpose. The conclusion is that such proposals of novelty are a diabolical distraction, diverting the faithful from the authentic prayer of the Rosary as transmitted by Tradition.
📜Tradition versus Fabrication in the Prayer of the Church
The proposal to introduce "synodal mysteries" into the Rosary exemplifies a mentality fundamentally opposed to the nature of Catholic prayer, whether liturgical or devotional. The prayer of the Church, in its highest and most stable forms, is a received reality—a paradosis—not a product fabricated by individual whim or by committees of experts. The Rosary, in its traditional form, is a treasure handed down through the centuries, the fruit of a piety that has matured in the faith and life of the Church. It is, in itself, a condensed form of living Tradition, through which the Church expresses her faith and her prayer (Kwasniewski, 2022).
The attempt to "expand" the Rosary with newly created sets of mysteries reflects the same error in principle that marked the post-conciliar liturgical reform. Instead of humbly receiving a sacred patrimony, one assumes the posture of a technician who builds new machines, discarding the old ones on the junk-pile. Authentic liturgy and devotions are not "fabricated" by authorities; they are the fruit of a dialogue of love between the Church and her Lord. The idea that an individual can, based on personal reflections on a contemporary concept like "synodality," design and propose an addition of 35 new mysteries, reveals a profound misunderstanding of what constitutes ecclesial prayer. Such an approach treats devotion not as a gift to be guarded, but as infinitely malleable clay, ready to be shaped according to the ideologies of the moment. This mentality is the antithesis of the reverence the Church has always shown for her forms of prayer, which are considered part of the Deposit of Faith (Kwasniewski, 2022).
🌱Organic Growth (Profectus) vs. Mutation (Permutatio)
Catholic Tradition recognizes the legitimacy of development but crucially distinguishes between organic growth (profectus) and mutation or corruption (permutatio). A true development, like the growth of a body, consolidates, expands, and refines what already exists, remaining faithful to its original nature and identity. In contrast, a mutation introduces a foreign form, which does not emerge from within but is imposed from without, resulting in deformity (Kwasniewski, 2022).
The traditional mysteries of the Rosary (Joyful, Sorrowful, and Glorious) represent the apex of a profectus. They crystallize the Church's meditation on the central events of the Incarnation and Redemption. Even the addition of the Luminous Mysteries, though a papal innovation, attempted to insert itself into the existing salvific logic. The proposal of the "synodal mysteries," however, represents a clear permutatio. Its logic derives not from the internal structure of the devotion but from an external and contemporary ecclesial agenda: "synodality." The "fruits" associated with these new mysteries—such as "inclusion," "dialogue," and "reciprocity"—are not the theological and moral virtues that spring from the contemplation of the life of Christ, but rather the values of a sociological and procedural paradigm.
This shift in focus, from Christ to the ecclesial process, from salvific events to human interactions, is a corruption of the very purpose of the devotion. The Rosary is not a tool to promote the agenda of the day; it is a path to union with God through the contemplation of the mysteries of our salvation. To introduce mysteries based on the activities and conflicts of the early Church, interpreted through a modern lens of "synodality," is to substitute the divine with the administrative, the mystery with methodology.
🔬The Reformist Mindset and the Dilution of Doctrinal Content
The mentality behind the creation of the "synodal mysteries" is identical to that which guided the liturgical reform: a pastoral utilitarianism and a desire for "relevance" that ultimately dilute doctrinal content. Just as the prayers of the traditional missal were rewritten to remove truths considered "difficult" for modern man—such as sin, judgment, the wrath of God, and the need for penance—the new Rosary mysteries divert attention from the pillars of the faith to procedural abstractions (Kwasniewski, 2022).
To contemplate the "Selection of St. Matthias" to obtain the fruit of "discernment" or the "Mission to Cornelius" for "conflict transformation" is to turn the Rosary from a meditation on God's acts in salvation history into a manual for personal development or ecclesial management. The theological richness of the traditional mysteries lies in their capacity to immerse us in the life of the Incarnate Word and His Most Holy Mother. The Annunciation is not merely about "receptivity" but about the mystery of the hypostatic union. The Crucifixion is not about "perseverance" but about the propitiatory sacrifice that redeems the world.
This substitution of the theological with the sociological, the supernatural with the functional, is a defining feature of the post-conciliar collapse. Prayer is reformatted to serve immanent ends, becoming a tool for spiritual self-help or community cohesion rather than an act of latreutic worship. The result is a horizontalized piety, which may seem "relevant" in the short term but lacks the density and depth necessary to sustain faith in times of crisis.
⚖️Lex Orandi, Lex Credendi: The Implications of a Re-invented Piety
The axiom lex orandi, lex credendi, lex vivendi states that the way we pray determines what we believe and, consequently, how we live. This truth applies both to the sacred liturgy and to the popular devotions that derive from it. The integrity of the traditional Rosary has formed generations of Catholics in the orthodox faith, nurturing a piety centered on Christ and Mary, on the reality of the Incarnation, the gravity of sin, and the glory of the Redemption (Kwasniewski, 2022).
The introduction of a re-invented form of prayer, focused on processes and sociological virtues, will inevitably form a different kind of faith. A "synodal Rosary" will lead not to the Catholic faith of Tradition, but to a faith that values dialogue over truth, inclusion over conversion, and process over dogma. It is the creation of a spirituality for the "synodal church," an entity that defines itself not by fidelity to an unchanging deposit, but by its capacity for perpetual "listening," "dialogue," and adaptation.
The crisis in the Church today is, to a large extent, the result of the disintegration of the liturgy (Kwasniewski, 2022). This disintegration extends to the devotions that once flourished in its fertile soil. The defense of the traditional form of the Rosary is not an act of rigidity or nostalgia but a defense of the Catholic faith itself. To reject such innovations is to insist that prayer must conform us to Christ, not be conformed to the passing agendas of an ecclesial bureaucracy. Tradition, whether in the Mass or in the Rosary, remains the only sure bulwark against the transvaluation of all values that plagues the Church in our time.
📚References
Kwasniewski, P. A. (2022). The once and future Roman rite: Returning to the traditional Latin liturgy after seventy years of exile. TAN Books.
f1descatholica.blogspot.com